James Kenton vs The State of Tennessee & Chadwick Jackson

Comparing Metal and Composite Roofing: A Guide for Informed Choices

Blue metal roof

Selecting the right roofing material is a pivotal decision for homeowners, influencing not only the appearance of their homes but also their long-term durability, maintenance costs, and environmental impact.

This guide by James Kenton discusses the unique attributes of both metal and composite roofing, examining material composition, cost considerations, and environmental impact. It sheds light on the unparalleled benefits of metal roofing, offering homeowners a roofing solution that not only prioritizes durability and sustainability but also elevates the aesthetic appeal and value of their homes.

Material Composition

Metal roofing, characterized by its composition of materials such as aluminum, steel, or copper, stands as a testament to durability and strength. Unlike composite roofing, which incorporates a blend of recycled plastics, rubber, and wood fibers, metal roofing stands tall against the elements. The inherent robustness of metal makes it an ideal choice for homeowners seeking a roofing material that can withstand the test of time.

Moreover, the versatility of metal roofing extends beyond strength. Homeowners can choose from various styles and finishes, from sleek and modern to classic and traditional. This adaptability ensures that metal roofing can seamlessly integrate into diverse architectural designs, offering a personalized touch that enhances the overall curb appeal of any home.

Durability and Longevity

In the realm of durability, metal roofing unquestionably outshines its composite counterpart. Renowned for its exceptional strength, metal roofing is impervious to weather elements, including heavy rain, snow, and hail.

The fire-resistant properties of metal roofs add an extra layer of protection, particularly in regions prone to wildfires. With minimal maintenance, metal roofs can easily surpass 50 years, providing homeowners with a robust, long-lasting solution that significantly outlasts the lifespan of composite roofing.

Composite roofing, while designed to be durable, may not match the longevity of metal roofing. Over time, composite materials are susceptible to issues such as rot, mold, and insect infestations. These factors can contribute to a shorter lifespan and may necessitate repairs or replacements, ultimately increasing the long-term cost of ownership.

Metal roof

Cost Considerations

While the initial cost of metal roofing may seem higher than some alternatives, it proves to be a wise investment over time. The durability and longevity of metal roofs result in minimal maintenance costs over their lifespan, mitigating the need for frequent repairs or replacements. This longevity, coupled with the reflective nature of metal roofing, contributes to energy efficiency and potentially reduces cooling costs, further enhancing its overall cost-effectiveness.

In contrast, composite roofing may offer a lower initial cost, making it an attractive option for homeowners with budget constraints. However, it’s crucial to consider the long-term costs associated with maintenance and potential replacements. The lower durability and lifespan of composite materials may result in higher expenses over time, negating the initial cost savings.

Environmental Impact

When considering environmental sustainability, metal roofing takes the lead. Many metal roofs are crafted from recycled materials, reducing the demand for new resources and contributing to responsible resource conservation. Furthermore, metal roofing is fully recyclable at the end of its life cycle, aligning with green building practices and fostering a closed-loop recycling system.

The reflective surfaces of metal roofs play a dual role in environmental stewardship. Firstly, they contribute to energy efficiency by reflecting a significant portion of the sun’s rays. This reduces the absorption of solar heat, lowering cooling costs and decreasing overall energy consumption. Secondly, the recyclability of metal roofing materials ensures that they can be repurposed into new roofing materials at the end of their life cycle, minimizing waste and environmental impact.

In comparison, while composite roofing often incorporates recycled materials, the manufacturing process may involve the use of chemicals. Additionally, the disposal of composite shingles at the end of their life cycle can be a concern, as these materials may not be as easily recyclable as metal.


Beyond the practical advantages, metal roofing offers a range of aesthetic benefits that contribute to the overall appeal of a home. The sleek, clean lines and minimalist design of metal roofs lend a contemporary touch that can enhance the modern aesthetic of homes. With a diverse range of finishes and color options, homeowners have the freedom to customize their roofs, ensuring a perfect match with the architectural vision of their properties.

Architectural flexibility is another key advantage of metal roofing. The malleability of metal allows for innovative designs, curved roofs, and unique architectural elements. This flexibility ensures that metal roofing is not just a practical choice but also a design asset, allowing homeowners to create distinctive and contemporary looks.

Red metal roof

Making an Informed Choice

As homeowners navigate the decision-making process, it’s essential to consider the long-term benefits and overall value that each roofing material brings to the table. Metal roofing emerges as the superior choice, offering unmatched advantages that span durability, longevity, cost-effectiveness, environmental sustainability, and aesthetic appeal.

1. Durability

The durability of metal roofing sets it apart as a robust and resilient option. Whether facing heavy rain, snow, hail, or the scorching sun, metal roofing stands steadfast, providing homeowners with peace of mind, knowing their investment will withstand the test of time.

2. Longevity

The longevity of metal roofing is a testament to its enduring quality. With a lifespan that easily surpasses 50 years, metal roofs outlast many alternative materials. This longevity not only reduces the frequency of replacements but also minimizes the environmental impact associated with the manufacturing and disposal of roofing materials.

3. Cost-Effective Investment

While the initial cost of metal roofing may seem higher, it proves to be a cost-effective investment over time. Minimal maintenance requirements and potential energy efficiency benefits contribute to lower long-term costs. Homeowners can enjoy the resilience of metal roofing without the burden of frequent repairs or replacements.

4. Environmental Stewardship

For those prioritizing environmental sustainability, metal roofing emerges as a responsible choice. Crafted from recycled materials and fully recyclable at the end of its life cycle, metal roofing aligns with green building practices. The reflective surfaces contribute to energy efficiency, reducing the overall carbon footprint of a home.

5. Aesthetics

Beyond practical advantages, metal roofing offers aesthetic benefits that enhance the overall appeal of a home. The sleek lines and minimalist design lend a contemporary touch, and the range of finishes and colors provide homeowners with the freedom to customize their roofs, ensuring a perfect match with their architectural vision.

Metal roof.

To seamlessly transition to metal roofing and experience the transformative benefits it brings, schedule a meeting with a trusted expert in the field. James Kenton, a seasoned metal roofing contractor based in Tennessee, stands ready to guide you through the process. Take the next step toward elevating your home by contacting James Kenton on Facebook today.

Scroll to Top